I’m simply astounded that, just like that, you’re abandoning me, the one who brought you into Jesus’ good graces, to run off after someone else’s version of Jesus. Mind you, there really isn’t any other legitimate version, but certain people (whose names I won’t mention) are taking you in. They want to make Jesus’ story into something else.
Nevertheless, even if we ourselves, or even a messenger from heaven, ever tell you anything different than what we first told you – well, to hell with them. I’ll say it again: if anyone ever tells you something other than what we’ve told you, to hell with them.
We can cut Paul a little slack. He’s feeling betrayed. He’s feeling like he’s losing his grip, and certainly his influence over a project that he was involved in from the beginning. Emotions are running high.
This is the point at which the partners in a start-up business have to tell the lead partner, “You’ve made this project too much about you. You’re a great go-getter, and you love the product like nobody else we know, but you just don’t work well with others, and you’re too controlling of the rest of the team. We’re sorry, but you’re fired.” You expect him to get a little upset. You expect him to tell you to go to hell. You expect him to write an open letter to the employees, and publish it on Facebook.
The truth of the matter is, we owe Paul a great deal. If it hadn’t been for him, most of us probably never would have heard of Jesus. Christianity would have remained an obscure little enclave of disaffected Jews and a few curious folk from other ethnic backgrounds. Jesus would have remained an historical footnote. But Paul wasn’t perfect.
Paul’s version of Jesus was, at the time, not in sync with what most of the people who had known Jesus personally were saying about him. At the time, Christianity was a Jewish fringe movement. It was tied to a few people’s experience of a single man.
Paul’s experience, and his version of Jesus, was visionary. It had the advantage of not being tied to the human experience of Jesus. It wasn’t parochial, geographically or ethnically, in the way the Jerusalem group was. It could spread. But the down side was that without the anchor of the real person, Jesus, the man who started the movement, Paul was free to envision all kinds of things that just weren’t part of the story. Since he claimed his visions came from the risen Jesus, who could argue?
Except that at some point, common sense takes over, and you have to let the lead partner go. It’s not easy. Never is. But you’ve got to do it, before the whole thing falls apart.